Joyless marriage not ground for divorce: UK Supreme Court

27 July, 2018, 21:56 | Author: Bert Pena
  • Tini Owens loses Supreme Court divorce fight

A WOMAN who wants to divorce her husband of 40 years because she says their marriage is unhappy has lost a Supreme Court fight.

"Unfortunately for Mrs Owens, the decision means she will be locked into a marriage that is clearly over, until 2020 when she can petition for divorce on the grounds of five years separation".

Under current United Kingdom law, which dates back 50 years, anyone seeking divorce must show that a marriage has broken down due to adultery, unreasonable behaviour or desertion, or live apart from his or her spouse for five years.

It's a complicated saga: Ms Owens says she first considered getting a divorce in 2012, but did not leave the family home until 2015 - issuing a divorce petition in May that year.

Simon Beccle, Mrs Owens' solicitor, said she had hoped the justices would make a decision which would be "forward-thinking and fit with the current social mores".

Resolution, an organisation that represents 6,500 lawyers working in family law and supports the introduction of no-fault divorce, said the judgment confirmed there was a "divorce crisis" in England and Wales. This led her to feel "unhappy, unappreciated, upset and embarrassed", and after many years, she said that she had "grown apart from him".

"The appeal of Mrs Owens must be dismissed".

Past year three appeal judges ruled against her after a Court of Appeal hearing in London. Politicians can no longer justify inaction on their part and must introduce no-fault divorce without delay.

Image Credit Wu Jianxiong  Unsplash
Image Credit Wu Jianxiong Unsplash

Hamish Dunlop, commenting on the Supreme Court judgement, told Lawyer Monthly: "The Supreme Court has rightly rejected Mrs Owens' attempt radically to reinterpret the requirements for a behaviour divorce brought under the Matrimonial Causes Act 1973".

Caroline Elliott of law firm Shakespeare Martineau said: "England and Wales lag far behind other countries with their divorce laws".

They argued she should not have had to prove Mr Owens' behaviour has been "unreasonable", only that she should not "reasonably be expected" to remain with him.

A wealthy couple, the Owens had been married since 1978 and have two grown-up children. "It is not for us to change the law laid down by Parliament - our role is only to interpret and apply the law that Parliament has given us". In particular, she felt that "this was a case which depended upon the cumulative effect of a great many small incidents said to be indicative of authoritarian, demeaning and humiliating conduct over a period of time" (paragraph 50), and that the hearing "was not set up or conducted in a way which would enable the full flavour of such conduct to be properly evaluated".

Another, Supreme Court president Lady Hale, said she found the case "very troubling".

She said she had been "reluctantly persuaded" that the appeal should be dismissed.

Previous courts found that her examples of his bad behaviour - needed to grant a divorce - were "flimsy" and "isolated incidents", with the case eventually making it's way to the Supreme Court.

Pakistan's Imran Khan on cusp of power, opponents cry foul
Before official results arrived, PTI and Khan supporters took to the streets to celebrate the initial results on Wednesday night. Monitors had been thrown out of polling stations as votes were tallied and results were unexpectedly delayed for hours.

What does the apparent Trump-EU trade truce mean for China?
The administration clobbers farmers with an unnecessary trade war then attempts to assuage them with taxpayer handouts. Beijing imposed tariffs on $34 billion worth of USA products, including soybeans, earlier this month.

First half of the week brings more afternoon rain & storms
We do have slightly better rain chances today , but it's not until later in the day and it won't be much. Wednesday will be mostly sunny and a little warmer with highs in the mid 80s and dew points in the 60s.

Recommended:



Popular

Saudi Arabia halts oil exports via Red Sea after Yemeni retaliatory attacks
James Dorsey, an expert on Middle East affairs, said the attacks on oil tankers would draw worldwide attention to Yemen. Oil prices are already high and it is not in the interests of the USA to see them go any higher.

Roseanne apologizes directly to Valerie Jarrett, then mocks her looks on 'Hannity'
Barr also indicated she felt like she had apologised enough for her actions. "I imagine you would say that about me", he said. I could fight this, because they didn't give me the notice or the chance to correct. 'That's why I'm allowing this podcast.

Putin soccer ball gift to Trump may have had microchip
But Russia also did not immediately jump at the opportunity to schedule a second summit between the two leaders. Putin's claims Russian Federation didn't interfere in the 2016 election.

JW: Documents show Federal Bureau of Investigation deceived secret court in obtaining warrant
A plurality of Americans think Trump's campaign colluded with Russian Federation , but 87 percent of Republicans think it didn't. The documents, available online after media outlets sued for their release, actually suggest the opposite.

Trump says China is being 'vicious' by hitting US farmers with tariffs
Nick VanWychen, a Kaukauna farmer, says soybeans are one of the crops most affected by trade disputes. President Donald Trump has ordered the Department of Agriculture to dole out $12 billion in aid.

Riyad Mahrez reveals he rejected other clubs to join Manchester City
But to become a top top team you have to learn how to play football with courage. "I think to have competition is really good". Now the attention turns towards the summer, and the players who could be moving clubs ahead of the 2018-19 season.

Demi Lovato net worth: Sober singer's HUGE 2018 net worth revealed
Fans of the singer were shocked after she revealed she had relapsed with new single, " Sober ", released in June. TMZ is reporting that Demi was rushed to a hospital after suffering what appears to be a heroin overdose.

Meghan Markle's sister hints at appearing in UK Celebrity Big Brother show
Meghan Markle's sister Samantha Markle is taken to hospital after a vehicle accident, she claims was caused by the Paparazzi. In the meanwhile, Markle's getting used to all this royal hubbub - from what to wear to how much PDA is too much.

President Trump on EU Trade Negotiations: Better Late Than Never
Trump wrote in a Twitter post Tuesday, warning countries must negotiate a "fair" trade deal or they will get hit with tariffs. Trade Expansion Act, which handles trade matters considered a threat to national security.

North Korea begins dismantling nuclear and ballistic missile facilities
The launch in February 2016 was particularly contentious because Pyongyang had conducted a nuclear test just a month earlier. Decades-old remains that North Korea has handed over in the past have not always been identifiable as USA troops.